Replacing Amalgam Fillings: What North Beach Patients Should Know
By North Beach Dental Care · · 9 min read
If you've got a mouth full of old silver fillings, you've probably wondered whether it's time to swap them for something more natural looking. Maybe you've read something online about mercury. Maybe you just don't love the grey glint when you laugh. Either way, it's a reasonable question, and one we hear often at North Beach Dental from patients across North Beach, Carine and Karrinyup who have had the same fillings for decades.
This article walks through what the evidence actually says about replacing amalgam fillings, when it's worth doing, and when your dentist might suggest leaving well enough alone.
What is an amalgam filling, exactly?
Amalgam is the silver-coloured filling material that's been used in dentistry for a very long time. Dental amalgam is a mixture of metals including silver, copper and tin with mercury forming a stable alloy. Once it's set hard inside your tooth, it's a stable, solid material, not a loose or leaking substance.
Amalgam has largely fallen out of favour in Australian dental practices over the past couple of decades, mostly because tooth-coloured materials have improved so much, and because of environmental rules around mercury. But many people still have amalgam fillings from years gone by, sometimes several of them, sitting quietly in their back teeth.
Is dental amalgam actually safe?
This is the question most people are really asking when they search for information on replacing amalgam fillings. The Australian Dental Association's own policy on this is clear and worth knowing before you make a decision.
When used in accordance with current regulations and in its approved capsulated form, dental amalgam remains a safe and acceptable restorative option where clinically indicated. The ADA also notes that the preponderance of available evidence does not link the presence of amalgam restorations with chronic and degenerative diseases, kidney disease, autoimmune disease, cognitive dysfunction, adverse pregnancy outcomes or any non-specific symptoms in the general population.
There are some groups where dentists take extra care. Dentists are advised to minimise the use of dental amalgam in children, pregnant or breastfeeding women and in individuals with kidney disease. If you have a genuine allergy to one of the metals in amalgam, that's also a reason your dentist might recommend a different material.
So why is amalgam being phased down at all, if it's considered safe? It comes down to the environment, not your health. Australia is part of an international agreement that limits mercury use broadly, including in dentistry, mainly to reduce mercury entering waterways and landfill during manufacture and disposal. It isn't a statement that your existing fillings are doing you harm.
Should amalgam fillings be replaced if they're not causing problems?
This is where the evidence is genuinely reassuring. There is no evidence that replacement of sound amalgam fillings by alternative materials, without clinical indications, produces a better health outcome for patients. In plain terms, swapping out a filling that's doing its job properly won't improve your health, and it does carry a small downside: every time a filling is removed, a little more of your natural tooth structure goes with it.
That doesn't mean you should never replace an amalgam filling. It means the decision should be based on what's actually happening with that tooth, not just its age or its colour. At your regular check-up, our team at North Beach Dental checks each filling for cracks, wear, leakage and any decay forming underneath, using a visual exam and X-rays where needed. If a filling is sound, we'll usually say so and leave it as is.
When replacing a silver filling with white does make sense
There are several situations where moving from amalgam to a tooth-coloured filling is a sensible step. Here are the main ones we see in the chair.
The filling is cracked, leaking or failing
Amalgam fillings don't last forever. Over the years, the edges can wear, chip or develop small gaps where the filling meets the tooth. If bacteria get into that gap, decay can start underneath the filling, sometimes without you feeling anything until it's picked up on an X-ray. This is one of the clearest, most practical reasons to replace an old filling, regardless of what material goes in next.
Decay has developed under or around it
Sometimes a filling looks fine on the surface but decay has crept in underneath. This is exactly why we recommend an exam and scale and clean about every six months, with bitewing X-rays about every two years for most people, though your dentist will set the timing that suits your own teeth. Catching this early usually means a smaller, simpler repair.
You'd simply prefer a natural look
Plenty of patients ask about replacing silver fillings with white purely for appearance. That's a completely valid personal reason, especially if the filling shows when you smile or laugh. Our team will talk through what's involved for your particular tooth, including how much of the original filling needs to come out and what a tooth-coloured replacement can realistically achieve, since results vary from person to person.
The tooth needs other work anyway
If a tooth already needs attention for another reason, it's often a convenient time to update an old amalgam filling with a tooth-coloured one in the same visit.
What replacing amalgam fillings with composite actually involves
Replacing an amalgam filling with composite, a tooth-coloured resin material, is a fairly routine procedure. Your dentist numbs the area, removes the old amalgam carefully, checks the tooth underneath for any decay, then rebuilds the tooth in layers using the composite material, shaping and polishing it to match your bite and the tooth beside it.
Composite bonds directly to the tooth, which can mean less healthy structure needs to be removed compared with the original amalgam placement. It's worth knowing that composite and amalgam each have their own strengths. Composite blends in visually and works well for small to moderate fillings. In some very large or heavily loaded back teeth, your dentist might discuss other tooth-coloured options such as an inlay or onlay, or in some cases a crown, if a filling alone isn't going to give the tooth enough support. We've covered that decision in more detail in our guide to how we decide between a crown and a filling.
Before anything is removed, our team explains what we're seeing in your mouth, what the options are, and what each one involves, including the costs, so there are no surprises partway through. You're always welcome to ask for the item numbers if you'd like to check them against your own health fund.
What affects the cost of replacing a filling
We won't quote figures here, because every tooth is different and prices change over time. What affects the cost is the size of the filling, how many surfaces of the tooth are involved, whether decay needs treating first, and which material is used. If you hold a policy with HBF, Medibank, HCF or nib, North Beach Dental is a preferred provider for those funds, which usually means a smaller gap for you to pay. If you're with a different fund, you can usually still claim, just at a different rate, so it's worth checking your policy or asking our front desk.
You can read more about the material itself on our tooth-coloured fillings page, which explains how composite fillings work and where they're used.
Frequently asked questions
Can you replace metal fillings with white fillings?
Yes, in almost all cases a metal amalgam filling can be replaced with a tooth-coloured composite filling. Your dentist will check the size and position of the existing filling first, since very large or heavily loaded back teeth sometimes need a stronger option such as an inlay, onlay or crown instead.
Do I need to replace all my amalgam fillings at once?
No. There's no need to replace every amalgam filling in one go, especially if most are sound and causing no problems. Many patients choose to update fillings one at a time, either as each one needs attention or gradually over several visits.
Will removing my amalgam fillings improve my health?
There's no good evidence that removing sound amalgam fillings improves general health for people without a specific allergy or medical reason. The main reasons people choose to replace them are appearance, or because the filling itself needs attention.
Does replacing a filling hurt?
Your dentist uses local anaesthetic to numb the area before removing the old filling, so you shouldn't feel the procedure itself. Some people notice mild sensitivity for a short time afterwards; if pain relief is needed, follow the directions on the pack or ask your pharmacist.
What if I have ongoing pain or swelling near an old filling?
A persistent ache, swelling or a bad taste near an old filling is worth getting checked promptly. If you develop spreading facial swelling, fever, trouble breathing or swallowing, or bleeding that won't stop, seek urgent care at a hospital emergency department rather than waiting for a routine appointment.
Our approach at North Beach Dental
We're a family-owned, established practice, and many of our patients have been coming to us for years, which means we often get to know a person's mouth, and their fillings, over a long period. If you've got old amalgam fillings and you're not sure whether they need attention, the simplest next step is a check-up where we can take a proper look, including X-rays, and talk through your options honestly. You can learn a bit more about our practice on our about us page, and if you're new to the practice, our new patients page has everything you need to get started. We also take the OPG, a panoramic X-ray that shows your whole mouth, right here at the practice, so there's no separate trip needed if one is recommended.
We'll never pressure you into replacing a filling that's doing its job. But if you'd like a clear answer on what's going on with your own teeth, or you're ready to move ahead with replacing amalgam fillings for appearance or comfort, we're happy to help. You can choose a time online or call North Beach Dental on (08) 9447 1514. We're located at 17 Lawley Street, North Beach, and our team often checks in after treatment to see how you're settling in. When you're ready, book a check-up online and we'll take it from there.
